Lansing - Michigan is closer to having more forgiving self defense laws. Lawmakers in Lansing discussed deadly force legislation Tuesday.
Some groups, like the National Rifle Association, say the laws will make Michigan a safer place. Others, like Million Mom March members, worry they're a license to kill.
Inside the State Senate's law committee some strong emotions provoked a little disorder.
Darin Goens of the National Rifle Association said, ?There is a need for this bill. People are under attack every day in this country.?
Shikha Hamilton of Million Moms March said, ?We have a right to self defense, but these bills do not deter crime, but invite unsavory behavior.?
The sponsor of the bills supporting someone's right to use deadly force - even outside their home - is the former Eaton County Sheriff.
Rep. Rick Jones| of Grand ledge said, ?If you actually believe you are feeling great imminent threat of death, or imminent rape?
Representative Jones' proposal would also give immunity to people who kill in self defense. State prosecutors don't like that.
Ron Frantz, an Ottawa county prosecutor says, ?We believe it creates message that deadly force can't be scrutinized and that's bad public policy.?
"People here have developed a make my day attitude, this protects law abiding citizens," says Kathy Bradbury of Brighton.
State Sen. Alan Sanborn of Macomb County said, ?This is really defending people who would observe the laws.?
Some senators - and a mother - wondered why the laws are needed
?What I haven't seen is a plethora of problems,? said State Sen. Gretchen Whitmer of Lansing.
Katherine Ross of Bloomfield Hills said, ?These bills pray on the fears of people.?
After today's action there were 5 affirmatives and 2 no votes.
The laws will soon go to the full senate.
John BumgardnerIn your voice
