BATTLE CREEK, Mich. — Andrea Boggio said she'd never step foot into the state of Florida because she was afraid she was going to die.
She put her fears aside earlier this year when ABC Network contacted her, asking if she'd be willing to take part in an upcoming special edition of 20/20, which would take a deep dive into the brutal murder of her cousin, Shelly Boggio.
"This is a story that needs to be told and people in places other than Michigan and Florida need to know about it," said Andrea. "Shelly's killing has been my whole life and at some point it needs to stop."
The story began in 1984 when Frank Boggio, along with his twin daughters, Shelly and Stacy, moved from Battle Creek to Kenneth City, Fla.—8 miles northwest of downtown St. Petersburg.
The family barely had a chance to settle into their new home state before their lives would change forever.
According to court documents, on the evening of May 5, 1985, Shelly, Stacy and another girl, Stephanie Forsythe, were with two men—James Dailey and Jack Pearcy. The next day, Boggio's mutilated body was pulled from the Intracoastal Waterway in Indian Rocks Beach. The documents went on to say Boggio was beaten, choked, stabbed 31 times and held underwater until she drowned.
A knife found in the water near Boggio's nude body was said to belong to Pearcy. When questioned later, Pearcy told detectives that Dailey killed the girl.
Pearcy, 64, stood trial in November 1986. He was convicted of first-degree murder. The state sought the death penalty but a jury recommended a life sentence.
Dailey, too, was found guilty of first-degree murder, with the jury coming back with the death penalty. His conviction was largely based on testimony from three jailhouse informants, claiming that Dailey shared graphic details of the murder.
More than three decades later, both men are still serving time in separate Florida prisons, with Daily continuing to proclaim his innocence.
The two-hour 20/20 investigation will follow Andrea as she visits Shelly's grave as well as the location along Indian Rocks Beach where Shelly's body was found
"It was horrible," said Andrea. "I was very emotional at the crime scene. I put Holy Water in the water and said a little prayer, and then two dolphins came up.
"I don't believe in coincidences so I took that as a sign.
"Then going to the cemetery was horrible. I looked at all my family laying there, and Shelly across the way, and I felt like she was alone."
The ABC program will also feature many interviews with people who have been directly involved for all 35 years of the case, including James Dailey himself.
"It's a gross injustice on the part of Florida," said Andrea. "A sentence was invoked and it needs to be carried out; the evidence has proven itself time and time again."
When asked if she were to ever be given a chance to have an in-person conversation with James Dailey, Andrea said her first question to him would be, "Please tell the truth."
"I don't need to know why, because there's not going to be any good answer to that."
Andrea hopes that by sharing her family's three-decade-long story to a national and international audience, that justice will ultimately come for Shelly.
"James Dailey asked for the death penalty when he was convicted in 1987," said Andrea. "35 years is long enough, isn't it?"
You can watch ABC 20/20's 'The Perfect Liar,' Friday, October 23 beginning at 9:00 p.m. ET on 13 ON YOUR SIDE.
More to explore:
►Make it easy to keep up to date with more stories like this. Download the 13 ON YOUR SIDE app now.